Andrea Marsman. Photo: Council on African Canadian Education
On June 11, Andrea Marsman posted a question to the Black Educators Association Facebook page:
HAS ANYONE IN NOVA SCOTIA EXPERIENCED or WITNESSED “ANTI-BLACK RACISM” in the SCHOOL SYSTEM?? AS A STUDENT? TEACHER? ADMIN? EPA? STUDENT SUPPORT WORKERS? PARENT?
OUR POWER IS IN OUR COMMUNITY AND OUR COLLECTIVE VOICE!!!!!!!!!
As a parent I had my son’s primary teacher ask me during parent visitation, if “all little Black boys were mischievous because my son and the other little Black boy in her class were a handful.” When I asked her to clarify, she stated and I quote “Well you don’t work do ya dear? you could always volunteer in the class and then you could see what I mean.” When I told her I had a job she said, and I quote, “oh, good for you dear, where do you work?” When I told her that I was a high school teacher, she nearly fell off the chair, at which point I told her I would be meeting with her and her principal.
The stories come from teachers:
And as a teacher being called angry/aggressive when you speak up…having others compare their March Break tan to my skin…being asked to fix things… because apparently sitting at my desk after school working equals care taker….hearing subs call students Negro/colored kids… the list goes on.
From students:
One of most hurtful things though, and unknowingly to them; is when the teachers would give their ever so brief (realllllll brief) lessons on American civil rights, talk about Harriet Tubman or maybe Rosa Parks, but no Afro-Canadian history whatsoever… Then the teacher would close the lesson by singling me out, as the only black face I’ve seen in twelve years (asides from my own siblings), and would ask, “do you have anything you’d like to add? Maybe some stories or experiences about your family?”
And from parents:
In junior high my daughter was called the n word by another student. It initially shocked my daughter but later that afternoon it hit her and they got into a fight in the middle of the classroom. Both girls received a one-day in-school suspension TOGETHER in the office for a day. No liaison officer called. No supports whatsoever for my daughter.
Asked if anything about these stories surprised her, Marsman said, “Absolutely nothing. Not one thing.”
But one thing did strike her. “It’s still the same battles that we had back when I was a student and all through my teaching career.”
Some of the stories (shared anonymously, with permission), have been compiled on the website for Educators for Social Justice Nova Scotia. On the page, Marsman is quoted as saying:
To combat racism within our education system we must openly acknowledge that its very foundation is rooted in an ideology of white supremacy. Racism is in the brick and mortar of every educational institution in this province. For African Nova Scotian students, anti-Black racism has contributed to a ‘sense of un-belonging’ and a learning environment fraught with challenges. Teachers have felt isolated, unsupported and silenced in fear of being labelled ‘sensitive,’ or even worse, ‘angry and/or radical.’
Back in 1994, the Black Learners Advisory Committee produced “The Black Learner’s Advisory Committee Report on Education: Redressing Inequality, Empowering Black Learners,” which came to be known as the BLAC report. The three volumes contained 46 recommendations.
BLAC became the Council on African Canadian Education (CACE), and in 2004, 10 years after the report, executive director Delvina Bernard told CBC that a third of the report’s recommendations had yet to be implemented.
The Winter 2004 edition of Ahennwa, the CACE magazine, was largely devoted to marking 10 years since the BLAC Report. In an article by Patrick Kakembo called “Taking Stock: The BLAC Report on Education,” Kakembo quotes from the 1994 report’s vision for education in Nova Scotia in 2001:
In 2001, we have an education system which is equitable,
accessible, inclusive for all learners… an education system capable and competent to work with each individual child in full recognition of their resources — social, intellectual, and physical… The system provides educational experiences that celebrate diversity; where every child is welcome and valued by sensitive teachers trained in multicultural and anti-racist approaches; …We envision an education system which recognizes and has high expectations of all members of its society to offer and do their best; a system which recognizes the value and the rewards it receives for developing the skills and talents of every citizen… By the year 2001, Nova Scotia’s education system has become a model for other countries to consider as they struggle with racism, classism, and religious intolerance within their systems and societies.
Kakembo, whose role in the Department of Education included implementation of the report’s recommendations, notes many positive steps have been taken since the release of the report. But, he writes:
Paternalistic attitudes persist. Our education system must reflect
the ideal of equality or be openly hypocritical. Equality is the most
powerful ideal which we espouse as Canadians. African Nova Scotians must be trusted to articulate the learning needs of their community, their children, and youth. Thus Government officials
and the education system need to listen more attentively to parents
and those entrusted to advise the Government and school boards.
Bernard, in the same issue of the magazine, likens the significance of the BLAC
Report to Brown versus Education, the 1954 US Supreme Court case which ruled racial segregation of children in public schools unconstitutional.
She says:
It is our equivalent in Nova Scotia, in terms of the transformative power it eventually holds, in terms of its weight and especially in terms of its impact on Black learners in the future. It has given us decision-making roles in our education and a forum for self-determination. We now preside over programming and resource decisions more than in the past.
Marsman remembers being a student in the pre-BLAC Report days. She said Grade 10 “was the first time in my entire school career that we even had a discussion around Black history… There was a little paragraph about African Nova Scotians back then, and it was about, I’d say, maybe less than 500 words.”
Marsman joined the Cultural Awareness Youth Group of Nova Scotia, led by writer and artist David Woods. “We had our own Black History Week, and we had a TV show, we had several conferences, and [the group had members] across the province,” she said. “And it was basically our only lifeline until the BLAC Report, at which times things changed.”
Ben Sichel, who teaches social studies and Spanish at Prince Andrew High, is one of the founders of Educators for Social Justice Nova Scotia. “I wish I could say I was surprised, but, you know, I have been a teacher for 14 years. I’ve heard lots of these types of stories before from Black colleagues and from students and families,” Sichel said in an interview. “It’s dispiriting, I guess, to read them all in one place like that. But I knew that those stories were out there for sure.”
Photo from Educators for Social Justice.
He says anybody who is surprised has not been paying attention.
“I’m sure there are white people who are going to be surprised by those things. And you see those kind of reactions on social media where people are like, ‘Wow, really? I can’t believe that happened to you,” Sichel said. “The BLAC report was 26 years ago and came up with very specific recommendations. And not all of those recommendations have been implemented… African Canadian Studies and African Heritage literature courses exist because of the BLAC report, because some Black parents and community members and teachers fought to have [them] implemented in the curriculum… But, you still see that there is an over-representation of Black students on IPPs and and in disciplinary actions and suspensions.”
Sichel also pointed out that students in the International Baccalaureate Program can’t take African Canadian Studies in Grade 11, because it conflicts. “What does it say when you can’t take that advanced program and also learn about African Canadian history?” he said. “It’s an example of a systemic sort of undervaluing of African Canadian history.”
And while regional centres for education may have policies designed to fight racism, policy alone is not enough.
A parent shared this story on the BEA Facebook page:
My son is now going into grade 5. Since he has started at the school he has been the subject of 4-5 different racially provoked incidents (that I know about)…
This school year I had enough and went into the school to talk to the principal… She informed me about the multicultural pedagogy that the school follows and told me they are doing everything by the book. I explained to her that it wasn’t enough; my son was still a target and a victim at her school with this pedagogy in place.
“We have lots of policies that speak to anti-racism,” Marsman said. “But the policies, of course, are only as good as the teachers who are upholding and enforcing them.”
Marsman said when she first started teaching, in 1994, “we used to have anti-racist education…It has since been changed to culturally relevant pedagogy… It’s kind of got, I would say, diluted, because now it’s all part and parcel of culturally relevant pedagogy.”
She added, “We’ve always talked about multiculturalism, which is not addressing anti-Black racism. We’ve talked about being inclusionary, which has not addressed anti-Black racism… Because of these stories and because historically it’s so painful and almost so unbelievable in many cases, a lot of people are very much afraid to address it.”
One of the first stories on the Educators for Social Justice Nova Scotia site says:
I remember 20 plus years ago, being in a staff meeting at my high school. We were discussing Anti-Racist Education (which has since been replaced with Culturally Relevant Pedagogy, two entirely different things) and teachers actually got up and walked out of the meeting in protest. They felt they were being attacked and didn’t want to hear it!!!
Marsman said ultimately, “the only real way to get at [anti-Black racism] is to be real, to rip that Band-Aid off and expose it for what it is. Call it what it is and address it no matter how painful it is. Teachers need to be properly educated around what it is and how to deal with it, how to recognize it, how to call it out. Because it’s not necessarily up to the teachers or the students of colour to do that for them. If we want to eradicate it, it has to be everybody. And it has everybody has to be on board. And it starts with believing that it actually exists, right?”
The Halifax Examiner is an advertising-free, subscriber-supported news site. Your subscription makes this work possible; please subscribe.
Some people have asked that we additionally allow for one-time donations from readers, so we’ve created that opportunity, via the PayPal button below. We also accept e-transfers, cheques, and donations with your credit card; please contact iris “at” halifaxexaminer “dot” ca for details.
Thank you!
I must begin by confessing my almost complete ignorance of Black history and of the Black Lives Matter movement, I was educated on military bases in the late 1970s and didn’t go to school with anyone of a different color until I went to Dartmouth High between 1979 and 1981. That said, I would put some of my time spent at home as we continue to deal with Covid-19 to good use and learn something. Where do you suggest I start?
Defund French immersion.
Defund the International Baccalaureate Programme.
Enforce school boundaries.
Use the money to improve the learning opportunities of kids from single parent homes,kids from low income homes and kids with special needs. Fund needs not wants. Pour money into poor communities.
HRM has money for middle class ‘wants’ but won’t even pay a few extra dollars to put a bus and a sidewalk into Africville.
They talk a good game at HRM council but turn their eyes away from improving the lives of our poor.
The council should think of the poor families in HRM as being cyclists, but cyclists stuck in a lane that is a circle of poverty and deprivation.
That’s the worst strategy I’ve seen in a while. I hope it’s sarcasm.
No. The first 2 items are not mandated programmes. There is no peer reviewed evidence that French immersion has any value. The worst test results come from schools with poor kids and Black kids.
What is your strategy for marginalized school kids ?
That’s nonsense. There’s plenty of peer reviewed research that French immersion is beneficial. What’s questionable is its impact on the remainder of the students. Those who need to ‘switch out’ or who are in English only. Those kids struggle More frequently as do kids in non academic or IB or AP streams. So do kids in poverty, with single parents etc etc. The problem is thinking we need to tear down what’s working for many kids in order to bring them down to the level who aren’t doing well. Let’s be honest. Even the best public education in NS is average nationally and nothing special internationally. Some of our university prof friends call it the ‘NS disadvantage’. The Local kids starting college here with enthusiasm but poor reading/writing/math skills. Learning two or more languages is always a benefit. Money doesn’t need to come from stripping what succeeds and pouring it into what does not. We’re spending a billion dollars over the next decade to twin highways. Use that $.
Let’s start by teaching children to read. On average, 30% of grade three students can’t read, it is much higher in some communities. We use programs that don’t work, Reading Recovery, we spend millions on this program and get very little in return.
It is so unjust to continue with these practices when we know we could do better by following evidence based practices.
It is my experience that french immersion has become an elitist program catering to predominantly white middle class families. I agree 100% with Colin. Sure put more french programming into mainstream schools but stop pretending that there is some kind of magnanimous social accomplishment by creating the french immersion system. We know where the marginalized students are showing up, and from what communities they are coming. I fully support the concept of putting resources where they are needed, not just wanted..
Strongly disagree. Why do you think French immersion costs anymore than English schooling? The benefits are priceless.