1. Tidal turbine

A photo of the tidal turbine.
The abandoned tidal turbine. Photo: Cape Sharp Tidal

“Energy and Mines Minister Derek Mombourquette announced last week the province intends to ‘eventually retrieve’ the abandoned 1,000-tonne, five-storey turbine abandoned at the bottom of the Bay of Fundy near Parrsboro,” reports Jennifer Henderson:

“Eventually” is the key word in that sentence since there is no timeline and no obvious financial means to pay a salvage bill estimated to cost at least five or six million dollars based on two previous deployments of the same turbine design.

Click here to read “Tidal recall: the province says it will pay the estimated $5 million to remove the tidal turbine abandoned on the floor of the Minas Basin, but doesn’t say when.”

This article is for subscribers. Click here to subscribe.

2. Sidewalks

The sidewalk along Gottingen Street in February 2015. Photo: Halifax Examiner

There’s weather today, and on cue, this morning the city issued five tender offers looking for contractors to clear sidewalks. One of the tender offers is misnamed on the main page of the province’s Tender websiteHRM-19-041 is listed as for Zone SWZ5 – Halifax Peninsula South, but it’s actually for Zone SWZ6A – Halifax Penninsula – West.

The other tender offers cover the correct offer for Zone SWZ5 – Halifax Peninsula South; Zone SWZ6B- Halifax Peninsula North, SWZ7- Halifax Clayton Park, Fairview Area; and Zone SWZ8- Dartmouth, Woodside/Lake Banook Area.

In 2017, Halifax council agreed to a plan that had consolidated 33 former zones into seven, and then entered into two-year contracts for those seven zones. Those contracts expire next Monday.

It appears the new zones are smaller than the previous zones, and perhaps more zones will be added to the tender site later today or tomorrow.

One thing jumps out at me: the contracts will be for four years, with the possibility of two-year extensions. I don’t know if this is the result of pressure from the contractors, or if city administration simply wants to kill any notion that sidewalk clearing can be brought back in house any time in the foreseeable future. I suspect the latter.

Halifax council will have to approve the contracts to the winning bidders, so there’s still time to intervene.

3. Shambhala

Mipham Mukpo

Carol Merchasin, who collaborated with primary author Andrea Winn on the Sunshine Reports that broke open the sex abuse allegations against Shambhala leader Mipham Mukpo and within the Shambhala organization generally, has penned an open letter in response to the Wickwire Holm investigation into those allegations.

You’ll recall that Wickwire Holm lawyer Selina Bath was hired by Shambhala International to look into the sex abuse allegations. In her open letter, Merchasin pointedly faults Bath for failing to properly investigate three areas, most notably the “Complicity of Shambhala Teachers and Other Leaders.” Merchasin writes:

In both the June and July 2018 BPS investigative memos, I raised concerns about leaders who were complicit in the Sakyong’s misconduct. There were credible witnesses supporting the allegation that David Brown, Jesse Grimes and Mitchell Levy knew that the Sakyong had sexually assaulted a woman in Chile in 2002.

Similarly, Joshua Silberstein, Wendy Friedman, Adam Lobel and others knew of the Sakyong’s assault in 2011. Some Shambhala leaders and teachers were also aware of the Sakyong’s misconduct in the 90s and early 2000s. For example, a woman who did not want her allegations investigated told me that after she reported to Shambhala that she was assaulted by the Sakyong in the early 2000s, someone was sent from Halifax to talk to her — not to assist her, but to make sure she did not make her experience public.

Yet, none of these allegations of complicity were investigated. This is not normal, nor right. It is certainly not a way to restore trust to a community.

It appears that the Interim Board did not want to know the answers to a number of questions. Certainly, they did not want to know about the sexual assault in Chile and perhaps as importantly, they did not want to know who knew, who covered up, or who was complicit in 2002, 2011 or any other time.

I am acutely aware of  the Interim Board’s loyalty to the Sakyong and possibly to some of the very people who were complicit. I recommended an independent monitor specifically for this reason — so that when all was said and done, there would be no concern about manipulation, about true independence, about the scope. 

What I know is that a portion of the investigation was halted in December and the issue of the complicity of Shambhala leaders was eliminated from the scope.  In 25 years of practice, I have never had a client that would dare to do either. I  do not understand how an organization whose mission is to create enlightened society can hold itself below the moral and legal minimums of the society it wants to enlighten.   

4. The Oak Island effect

Used to be, when I travelled to the states, the only thing Americans knew about Nova Scotia was Anne Murray; now they’re always asking me about Oak Island.

The Curse of Oak Island TV series has got to be the the most successful scam in local history.

Oak Island pops up in what must be Aly Thomson’s last article for the Canadian Press, which looks at treasure salvaging legislation in Nova Scotia; one diver, Jeff MacKinnon, says that by mostly outlawing treasure hunting, the legislative changes have encouraged looting. Thomson writes:

Meanwhile, treasure hunting is being carried out with great fanfare on Nova Scotia’s south shore on Oak Island, the subject of a popular History channel television show, “The Curse of Oak Island.”

The provincial act that regulates that project – the Oak Island Act – was enacted after the Treasure Trove Act was repealed to allow work on the small island to continue.

MacKinnon believes it’s unfair that treasure hunting is allowed to happen on Oak Island while other, perhaps even more culturally significant sites, sit largely unexplored on the ocean floor.

He said it’s also a missed opportunity, given the commercial success of the television show. There are plenty of known sites that could make for their own television shows or documentaries, and in turn, promote the province and ultimately boost tourism, he said.

Oh, great. Soon we’ll get a bunch of credulous Americans tromping over the place looking for wrecks and fortune.

But if we’re going to make it provincial policy to separate fools and their money, may I suggest going after the Chinese variety of fool? There are more Chinese than Americans, and a lot of them have more money.

Remember the nonsense that was The Island of the Seven Cities? Based on no evidence at all, Paul Chiasson wrote an entire book claiming that in the 15th century the Chinese sailed to Cape Breton, built a city, and then got the Mi’kmaq to wear Chinese dress. It was patently absurd, but that didn’t stop CBC reporter Tom Murphy from doing a non-skeptical segment that was aired on The National:

YouTube video

For sure, like The Curse of Oak Island, the Chinese City in Cape Breton is utter bullshit, but that shouldn’t stop us from profiting from it. Some enterprising filmmaker should work up a proposal and shop it to whatever the Chinese version of the History Channel is, the McNeil government can subsidize a Hong Kong-to-Sydney ferry, and lickety-split, we’ll have Chinese tourists filling up the airbnbs.

5. Women

Stephen Kimber has a short essay in Atlantic Business looking at the role of women in media and business:

The mere presence of more women, not only inside newsrooms but also, increasingly, in positions of power in news organizations, has changed our definition of news for the broader and better.

Can you imagine the New York Times, circa 1979, committing the resources necessary to uncover bad behaviour by the likes of Harvey Weinstein, Bill O’Reilly et al? And giving those stories such prominent display we are now in the middle of an historical #metoo reckoning? I can’t.

Or how about the managers at the Globe and Mail allowing reporter Robyn Doolittle to spend 20 months gathering data from 870 police forces, crunching numbers and writing previously unwritten stories demonstrating conclusively how our police forces consistently refused to believe women who said they’d been raped?

Changing the composition of newsrooms changes our definition of news. For the better. The same, of course, could/should be said of businesses and boardrooms.

We should be celebrating — or at least marking — those changes, but we should also be noting just how much work we still need to do. There is still a distinct lack of diverse voices (indigenous, African Canadian, those of other colours, immigrants) telling their stories and making those stories part of our shared experience. In the media. And in the business world.




Halifax and West Community Council (Tuesday , 6pm, City Hall) — a public hearing for a proposed three-storey apartment building on Inglis Street.



Community Design Advisory Committee (Wednesday, 11am, HEMDCC Meeting Space, Alderney Gate) — if you for some reason wants to completely waste your time by going to a meeting that will discuss the completely meaningless Centre Plan, here’s your chance. But consider: you could instead clean the lint out of your navel, or alphabetize your spice rack, or use a ouija board to try to communicate with the Egyptian god Horus (the fellow with the falcon head, pictured above) — any one of which would be a far more productive activity with far more useful real-world results than worrying yourself about the Centre Plan.



Health (Tuesday, 9am, Province House) — about Cape Breton hospitals.

Law Amendments (Tuesday, 11:15am, Province House) — the committee will consider Bill No. 122 – An Act to incorporate the Pine Grove Cemetery Company, Lower Stewiacke, Colchester County (amended)

Legislature sits (Tuesday, 1pm, Province House)


Public Accounts (Wednesday, 9am, Province House) — I very much want to post another picture of Horus here, but I’ve already used that joke.

Legislature sits (Wednesday, 1pm, Province House)

On campus



Nothing worth writing home about.


A memory foam model of evolutionary mechanics: entropy and epistasis drive molecular evolution (Wednesday , 4pm, Theatre A, Tupper Medical Building) — David Pollock from the University of Colorado, Aurora, will speak.

Jodi Lazare. Photo: Rachael Kelly

Our Legal Relationship with Animals (Wednesday, 7pm, Room 104, Weldon law Building) — Jodi Lazare talks about how we relate to animals, legally.

Mount Saint Vincent


Rethinking Violence from Modernity’s Epistemic Territory (event on Monday, April 15, 12pm, McCain Centre 105) — Today and Wednesday are the last days to RSVP here. Claudia Brunner from the University of Klagenfurt will speak. More info here and here.

In the harbour

06:00: Dalian Express, container ship, arrives at Fairview Cove from Colombo, Sri Lanka
06:00: Julius-S, container ship, arrives at Pier 41 from Lisbon, Portugal
06:00: John J Carrick, tank barge, arrives at McAsphalt with tug Leo A. McArthur from Montreal
06:30: Nolhanava, ro-ro cargo, arrives at Fairview Cove from Saint-Pierre
08:30: US Coast Guard Cutter Campbell, sails from Dockyard for sea
09:00: USS Jason Dunham, U.S. naval destroyer, sails from Dockyard for sea
09:00: Ferbec, bulker, sails from Pier 25/26 for sea
15:30: Manon, car carrier, arrives at Autoport from Southampton, England
16:30: Julius-S sails for New York


We’ll publish an article by Joan Baxter later today.

I’m behind on everything, but gotta shovel out first.

Sometimes my headlines are personal SEO jokes. Slap “Oak Island” in the headline, and google dot come works some serious magic. (Because we have no advertising, the Examiner doesn’t make any money from people simply coming to Morning File; that requires real subscriptions.)

I have no coppyeditor today. Please be kind.

The Halifax Examiner is an advertising-free, subscriber-supported news site. Your subscription makes this work possible; please subscribe.

Tim Bousquet is the editor and publisher of the Halifax Examiner. Twitter @Tim_Bousquet Mastodon

Join the Conversation


Only subscribers to the Halifax Examiner may comment on articles. We moderate all comments. Be respectful; whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims. Please read our Commenting Policy.
  1. It’d be nice to imagine that Oak Island myth sucks in all kinds of gullible outside money, but his highly profitable History Channel show is also given truckloads of subsidies from the Nova Scotia government. Who are the real suckers?

  2. Sobek would like me to remind you that he is the Egyptian god of choice for the Youtube generation. Horus is ‘played out’, he growled at me. Then he ate my tv.

  3. The reason Oak Island can have special status under the Special Places and Treasure Trove Acts is that it is one place in the province where there is WITH ABSOLUTE CERTAINTY no treasure or anything of historic or archeological value whatsoever. It has been picked over, blown up, plowed, graded and dug for over a century.

    Common sense would say that if there is anything of value there the government would be taxing it, monitoring it, heritage groups would be protecting it, and so on.

    It’s the very antithesis of the very notion of treasure, where something (known) is lost or hidden and must be found. At Oak Island the story is reversed. Here’s a hiding place. A black box. What could be in it?

    It’s an amazing scam that rolled through generations. And there is no denying its success.

    1. But how long until all the treasure hunting, hucksterism, media productions and other human activities on Oak Island make it a genuinely historical place?