On campus
In the harbour


1. Public Accounts

Tom Traves
Tom Traves

The province yesterday published the public accounts for the 2015-16 fiscal year, which ended March 31.

I’ve been slowly going through the documents, and as I find interesting items I’ll report on them.

For now, I’ve just scanned for the big salaries. As reported in the public employee compensation reports, the highest paid provincial employee appears to be former Dalhousie University president Tom Traves, who retired in 2013. Traves was paid $473,256, which is more than the actual working president, Richard Florizone, earned ($409,929). Traves’ contract included a three-year post-retirement salary at his highest annual working wage, and last year was the final year of that contract.

I suspect some doctors may be making more than Traves, but I don’t believe that information is public in Nova Scotia.

The university presidents seem to be among the highest paid employees. It’s interesting to do a comparison of salaries by university enrolment. Here are the bigger salaries (enrolment figures are for the last year available, not necessarily 2015):

Richard Florizone: $409,929
Students: 19,737
Cost per student: $20.77

Saint Mary’s
Robert Summerby-Murray: $261,046
Students: 7,447 (2013)
Cost per student: $35.05

Ray Ivany: $300,494
Students: 4,358
Cost per student: $68.95

Saint Francis Xavier
Kent MacDonald: $370,400
Students: 5,127
Cost per student: $72.24

Cape Breton University
David Wheeler: $262,000
Students: 3,000
Cost per student: $87.33

I don’t know that $200,000 or $300,000 is overly paid for a university president (but $400,000 is overly paid for any job), and a cost-per-student breakdown isn’t completely fair because the smaller universities will have smaller administrative staffs so presumably there’s more burden on the president. It’s not so much the president’s salary that concerns me, but more the overall administrative costs, and those are soaring. That’s especially disconcerting when the universities are slashing their full-time professor ranks and imposing ever-increasing tuitions on cash-strapped students.

2. Linden Lea

A developer wants to tear down the three-storey apartment building across from the Linden Lea duck pond in order to build a four-storey apartment building. Photo: Halifax Examiner
A developer wants to tear down the three-storey apartment building across from the Linden Lea duck pond in order to build a four-storey apartment building. Photo: Halifax Examiner

“Halifax regional council voted Tuesday night to move forward with a controversial development,” reports Zane Woodford for Metro:

About a dozen people spoke at the public hearing at Tuesday’s special meeting of council — more than two thirds of them against the proposed 41-unit building at 8 Linden Lea in Dartmouth.

The development, dubbed Pemberley Suites, is proposed by Milestone Properties. It would mean the company’s more affordable 12-unit building currently on the site would be torn down.

3. Fire

A water bomber at the Seven Mile Lake fire in Annapolis County. Photo: Communications Nova Scotia
A water bomber at the Seven Mile Lake fire in Annapolis County. Photo: Communications Nova Scotia

When I worked in California, I regularly covered wildfires that were 100,000+ acres, so it’s hard to get too excited about Nova Scotia’s Seven Mile Lake fire, which has grown to 240 hectares overnight. Still, no matter how large, fires are dangerous — especially for the firefighters. It’s damn hard work, plugging away for 14 hours a day in extreme heat made even hotter by the fire. And there is a real risk to life.

After concern for the firefighters, the biggest worry is for private homes; I haven’t seen any reports of houses being threatened, so that’s good. The forest itself could use the occasional burn. Left to its own devices, which unfortunately seems unlikely, the forest will be healthier in a few years, thanks to the fire.

4. Oven

Someone vandalized the community oven in the Dartmouth Common, reports Elizabeth Chiu for the CBC.

5. Free advertising

Newspapers are seeing advertising revenues collapse, and yet Metro is giving away free advertising.

For instance, on Monday Metro published an “article” written by Canadian Press writer Adina Bresge that doesn’t even pretend to be objectively looking at the Harbour Hopper, but rather reads as a straight-up advertorial for the boat.

And today Metro plugs the Swedish unfinished product store with a front page news article by Yvette d’Entremont, also without a contrary or even questioning word about the company, the expansion of Dartmouth Crossing, or the effect of the store on local retailers.

These companies would have paid thousands of dollars had they purchased similarly placed advertising, and yet Metro is just giving it away for free.


1. Supreme Court


“It’s the sort of slight that Atlantic Canadians normally bristle at,” writes Peter Cowan for the CBC:

Last week, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said he’d be OK with the country’s top court having no representation east of Quebec, and there was barely a peep out of provincial politicians in the region.


After decades of Atlantic Canada being guaranteed one seat on the court, that has now been stripped away.


Just think if former prime minister Stephen Harper had pulled a similar move. Politicians in Atlantic Canada would have gone ballistic, especially because Trudeau is letting Quebec keep its guaranteed three seats that are enshrined by law. Atlantic Canada’s one seat on the court was through constitutional convention, not legislation.

The problem, continues Cowan:

During the last election Atlantic Canada bet big on Big Red.

All 32 MPs are Liberal.

All four premiers are Liberal as well.

I don’t know anything much about regional Supreme Court appointments and how that translates into justice — I care about the court’s decisions and not where the judges call home — but maybe I’m missing out on an entire area of jurisprudence.

Still, when it comes to Atlantic Canada’s Liberal MPs and premiers failing to challenge the Trudeau government, I worry more about political effects than judicial decisions.

For instance, as Richard Starr has repeatedly pointed out, the Atlantic provinces are losing out on billions of dollars in health transfers because the Trudeau government has refused to reverse the Harper government’s ill-conceived changes to the equalization formula. If the changes aren’t reversed, Nova Scotia in particular will soon face a fiscal crisis. It’s a disservice to Atlantic Canadians that not a single premier or MP is raising the issue publicly.

2. Cranky letter of the day

To the Inverness Oran:

After being away from the county for the past 56 years, I have seen a lot of changes since returning last October.

Many of these changes have not been, in my opinion, for the betterment of the people of the county or the public in general.

Inverness business district has deteriorated over the years; hotels, motels, theatres, grocery stores, and restaurants have all disappeared. Worst of all, public access to the jewel of Inverness, its beachfront, has been overtaken by a golf course.

From the drawings in last week’s article by April MacDonald, about the unveiling of the “luxury beach cottages” proposed by Cabot Links, I wonder if the beach will still be for the public and tourists or will it belong to Cabot Links?

Public access now is restricted to a single road — the Beach Road.

Whatever happened to the second Beach Road access, the walking trails used by our parents and ourselves for over 100 years? What has happened to the sand dunes which reached over 100-200 feet from the high tide mark along this beautiful beach front?

Does the province of NS protect the public access to the waterways of the province and its ocean beachfronts? 

A second road access to the beach is a safety issue for all who use the full beach area. A drowning victim, heart attack victim, or a sunstroke victim at the upper end of the beach near the cottages RV park cannot get emergency medical response services in a timely way, which could save their lives.

Do we have to wait for someone to die on the beach before something is done to provide for safe, full access to our beachfront? I hope not.

A second access road connecting along the beachfront with the existing Beach Road would provide full access for the people of Inverness, tourists, and emergency services as well.

Sincerely yours,

Alex MacDonald, Inverness



Regional Watersheds Advisory Board (5pm, Alderney Library) — here’s the agenda.


No public meetings.

On campus


Thesis Defence, Math (9am, Room 3107, Mona Campbell Building) — PhD candidate Huda Chuangpishit will defend her thesis, “Geometric Embedding of Graphs and Random Graphs.”

Graphs (2:30pm, Chase Building, Room 319) — L. Sunil Chandran will talk on “Separation Dimension of Graphs and Hyper Graphs.” His abstract:

The separation dimension of a hyper graph G is the smallest natural number k for which the vertices of G can be embedded in R_k such that any pair of disjoint edges in G can be separated by a hyperplane normal to one of the axes. Equivalently, it is the smallest possible cardinality of a family F of total orders of the vertices of G such that for any two disjoint edges of G, there exists at least one total order in F in which all the vertices in one edge precede those in the other. It can be shown that the separation dimension of a hyper graph G equals the boxicity of the line graph of G, where boxicity of a graph H is defined as the smallest integer d such that H can be represented as the intersection graph of d-dimensional axis parallel boxes. In this talk we discuss the relation of separation dimension with various other graph theoretic parameters. We will also mention some of the recently introduced variants of separation dimension: Induced separation dimension! (from the team of Martin Golumbic) and fractional separation dimension (D. B. West and S. Loeb).

In the harbour

The sea around Halifax, 9am Wednesday. Map:
The sea around Halifax, 9am Wednesday. Map:

5am: Bahri Hofuf, ro-ro cargo, arrives at Fairview Cove from Baltimore
5am: NYK Nebula, container ship, arrives at Fairview Cove from Rotterdam
6am: ZIM New York, container ship, arrives at Pier 42 from New York
6am: Scotia Tide, barge, moves from Bedford Basin to Pier 9
6am: ZIM Monaco, container ship, arrives at Fairview Cove from Valencia, Spain
8:45am: Latgale, oil tanker, arrives at anchorage from New York for inspection
10:30am: Grandeur of the Seas, cruise ship, arrives at Pier 22 from Saint John with up to 2,000 passengers
10:30am: New Breeze, oil tanker, moves from Bedford Basin anchorage to Imperial Oil
Noon: Scotia Tide, barge, moves from Pier 9 to Bedford Basin
1pm: Bahri Hofuf, ro-ro cargo,sails from Fairview Cove for Livorno, Italy
4pm: NYK Nebula, container ship, sails from Fairview Cove for New York
4:30pm: ZIM Monaco, container ship, sails from Pier 41 for New York
4:30pm: ZIM New York, container ship, sails from Pier 42 for Kingston, Jamaica
6pm: CSL Tacoma, bulker, sails from National Gypsum for sea
6pm: Scotia Tide, barge, moves from Bedford Basin to Pier 26
7pm: Grandeur of the Seas, cruise ship, sails from Pier 22 for Baltimore
8pm: Atlantic Star, container ship, arrives at Fairview Cove from New York

5:30am: Talia, car carrier, arrives at Autoport from Bremerhaven, Germany
6am: NYK Diana, container ship, arrives at Fairview Cove from New York

Scotia Tide, carrying the tidal turbine. Photo: Halifax Examiner
Scotia Tide, carrying the tidal turbine. Photo: Halifax Examiner

The Scotia Tide, carrying the first of two tidal turbines destined for the Minas Basin, is obviously still in Halifax. That’s because there is a problem. The company reported last week:

In mid-July, we were advised by OpenHydro that they were investigating a potential issue with the metal properties of a fastening component in its Open-Centre Turbines. An OpenHydro investigation traced the issue to a supplier, and last week, lab testing confirmed that a risk exists with the long term durability of this component. The component was not locally sourced.

While considered a minor element of the overall system, the components are used to secure part of the turbine generator in position, and could fail prematurely if not replaced. Long term performance and reliability are key priorities, and so the decision has been made to replace the components in the Open-Centre Turbines.

Of key importance is that this is not an issue with the turbine design, rather a matter of incorrectly supplied components. Part of the purpose of this demonstration phase is to identify all potential issues, and OpenHydro is taking the appropriate steps to remedy the issue.

The component is inside the turbine so the rotor must be removed to gain access. Last week, work began in Pictou on turbine 2 as it is already in a horizontal position. OpenHydro is currently considering options for replacing the components in turbine 1.

Cape Sharp Tidal is not yet in a position to provide an update on deployment timelines as it is dependent on remedying the situation. We will continue to update stakeholders with new information as it becomes available.

In the meanwhile, the Scotia Tide is being shifted around the harbour to make room for other ships as needed.


I’ll be on The Sheldon MacLeod Show, News 95.7, at 2pm.

Please consider subscribing to the Examiner. Just $5 or $10 a month goes a long way. Or, consider making a one-time contribution via PayPal. Thanks much!

Tim Bousquet

Tim Bousquet is the editor and publisher of the Halifax Examiner. Twitter @Tim_Bousquet Mastodon

Join the Conversation


Only subscribers to the Halifax Examiner may comment on articles. We moderate all comments. Be respectful; whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims. Please read our Commenting Policy.
    1. Sean, I find it incredibly funny how left-wing the environmental and limits-to-growth types are, when a rational look at just how bad things really are might lead to different conclusions.

  1. I don’t agree with the need for regional representation on the Supreme Court, except for Quebec’s three, because Quebec has an entirely different system of civil law and judges are needed with expertise in that system. Whether that should be three or just one or two judges is a different discussion, but there I think there is a valid reason to have regional representation.

    But on the rest of the court, so what? Let the best candidate win. Also, this change allows Atlantic judges to compete for the other five common law seats when they come up.

    If regional representation is such a big deal, why has Newfoundland and Labrador never once had a judge on the court since it joined Canada in 1949? PEI has only had one judge, ending his term in 1924.

    I strongly agree with the diversity part — as a legal commentator (commenter?) put it, there are other and more important forms of representation in 2016 than where in the country you happen to live.

    The bilingualism part I am still not sure about, although I do understand the rationale behind it. If a case is argued in a language the judge doesn’t understand, it isn’t the same to hear it through an interpreter and that wouldn’t happen in lower courts — they’d assign a judge who could understand French or English, as the case may be. Nonetheless, this will give the province where I live, New Brunswick, a huge advantage, because I don’t know if any of our judges are not bilingual. Maybe some of the old folks ready to retire, but I don’t think we have appointed anything but bilingual judges for years.

    Regional representation on a court of law seems to me to be parochial. I don’t care where the judge is from. I want a good judge.

  2. Metro has a strange way of classifying its articles. The Harbour Hopper article should have run in the Travel section; its certainly not News. Yet the current cancellations and delays at Delta are filed under Travel.