On campus
In the harbour


1. #getalife

Matt Whitman
Matt Whitman

When I lived in Chico, a small town in the Sacramento Valley in northern California, I used to go to the library and read the 19th-century newspapers on microfilm. I learned that 19th-century Chico was a stereotypical western town, with wooden sidewalks, dozens of saloons patronized by hundreds of unruly cowboys, and most important, stoic law enforcement officers.

The western movies got that part right: the sheriff really was a bad ass.

Most towns (including Chico) quickly left the sheriff model behind and created an actual police force, but the cops were still bad asses. Their job, basically, was to be the tough dudes upholding civilization. They would patrol the streets at night, make sure the drunks weren’t getting too out of hand, and if so, drag them to the drunk tank and let them sleep it off. The cops regularly, nearly every night, got in fist fights and worse, but because they were so bad ass, they could handle it.

That spirit remained in law enforcement for a century and more, even here in Canada. Here’s how Jacob Boon describes the competition to become a cop in Halifax in the 1970s:

If you wanted the job back then, you had to fight for it. Police applicants in the ’70s were brought down to the department’s gymnasium and placed in a boxing ring with the largest opponent that could be found. The top brass would stand along the upper balcony, watching.

“You went toe-to-toe,” says Tom Martin. “You had to be able to hold your own.”

A lot of bad stuff came out of that tough-dude mentality, but let’s leave that aside and concentrate on the good stuff. Because it really was praise-worthy. The story we told ourselves was that cops were that thin blue line between civilization and utter chaos. Cops went out there every day and put their lives on the line, or at least risked personal danger, so that the rest of us could go to work and raise families and walk in the park without worrying about being robbed and attacked and worse.

It was always understood that cops were accepting some degree of risk. Sure, that mentally unstable person probably wasn’t a physical danger, but he might’ve been, and the cop would have to wrestle him down and bring him to the psych ward. That two-bit criminal was probably just a pathetic loser, but even pathetic losers might carry a knife, and the cop had to arrest him.

And for accepting that personal risk so the rest of us could have lives of relative peace, we rightly valourized cops. They were heroes.

But something happened along the way. In the public mind, the heroes had to be protected at all cost, because they were heroes. The very thing that made them heroes — accepting personal risk — is now the thing that is no longer allowed — any risk is too much to ask of them.

We see this attitude at its ludicrous extreme sometimes. A disturbed kid on a streetcar poses no conceivable risk to anyone at all, but maybe in some parallel universe the kid has a hidden gun so better to just shoot the kid dead and protect the cop. People shot dozens of times for looking the wrong way. A man gunned down in cold blood as he reaches for his wallet on a traffic stop.

And not only are cops no longer expected to accept any personal risk whatsoever, they’re now beyond criticism.

Take the case of Action Man Scott Warnica.

As El Jones pointed out Saturday, Warnica is such a tough guy he’s afraid of taking public transportation:

Scott Warnica is a staff sergeant with the Nova Scotia RCMP and an incident commander with the highly-trained Emergency Response Team — capable of employing specialized weapons, equipment and tactics to resolve high-risk situations.

Action Man Scott Warnica and his wife. Photo: CBC
Action Man Scott Warnica and his wife. Photo: CBC

Warnica knows how quickly things can go bad and how motivated terrorists can be, but said he’s comfortable taking his wife to the Games.

“Most of the terrorist threats occurred after we bought our tickets,” he said. “I think if you keep your wits about you and pay attention to your surroundings I think you’ll be fine.”

Warnica is already planning this trip with his training in mind.

“We have to get from our cruise ship in Sochi to the Olympic park —​ a distance of 12 kilometres,” he said.

“We’re going to avoid public transportation, avoid a lot of the public areas if we can.”

Scott Warnica believes the games will be safe, but he knows a terrorist would see spectators as valuable targets. His wife said all the talk about the danger is already a win for terrorists, especially because athletes are thinking about it.

So much for accepting any degree of personal risk. The other million tourists at Sochi were braver than the RCMP cop, and even, gasp!, took the bus.

And then last week, Halifax councillor Matt Whitman dared question Warnica.

Don’t get me wrong, Whitman can be a bit of an oafishly silly man. I don’t know how it happened exactly, but somehow his reverse-networking, weird Jesus cult thing morphed into one of the strangest Twitter accounts in Halifax.

During last week’s snowstorm, one of Whitman’s neighbours was clearing the cul-de-sac with an ATV fixed with a snow plow. This for some reason irked Warnica, who ticketed the neighbour for something or another.

Who knows? Maybe the neighbour deserved to be ticketed, but the ticket struck Whitman as small minded, and he said so on that strange Twitter account, using the hashtags #GetALife and #PowerTrip. (The tweet has been deleted.)

Was this impolite? Sure. But you know, it’s just Twitter. It’s not like Whitman was asking Warnica to take the bus.

Still and all, nowadays we can’t criticize the cops, because they’re heroes! Heroes who can accept no personal risk, not even the risk of criticism, but heroes all the same.

I get criticized every day on Twitter. You know what I do about it? I shrug it off because criticism is part of everyday life for a commentator. Arguably, criticism is also part of everyday life for a cop, but you know what Scott Warnica did when Whitman criticized him on Twitter? He called the mayor.

Think about how thin Warnica’s skin must be. You can probably see through it, right down to his frightened nerves.

This would simply be the story of a laughably thin-skinned cop, except city council yesterday took Warnica’s complaint and ran with it. Someone criticized a cop! Oh noes!

And so council went into closed session for two, then three hours to discuss the matter. Councillors came out of closed session long enough to eat dinner and hold a scheduled public hearing, but then went back into closed session to discuss it some more. I had better things to do than sit around and wait for council to announce that No one should ever criticize a cop ever, so I went about my night. I followed along on Twitter, however, and after four hours of secret discussion, council ordered Whitman to apologize to Warnica.

Yesterday just happened to be the four-year anniversary of the publication of A Trust Betrayed: Peter Kelly and the estate of Mary Thibeault. Readers will remember that after the article came out, councillors refused to discuss the matter at all. There were no in camera meetings about it. No councillor would be interviewed about it. It’s as if nothing had happened.

So here’s how it goes with Halifax city council: The mayor can secretly transfer $140,000 from a dead woman’s bank account into his own bank account, and no councillor will say a word. But when a councillor hurts a cop’s fee-fees, council goes into closed session for four hours and demands an apology.

2. Beer Garden

Photo: Yelp
Photo: Yelp

Back in 2013, the folks at Bar Stillwell approached the Waterfront Development Corporation and asked about the possibility of selling beer on the boardwalk. As Remo Zaccagna reported at the time:

More than a year ago, [Stillwell’s three owners] approached the provincial Waterfront Development Corp. with the idea for the beer garden.

“We looked at all kinds of spots, from parking lots, to empty spots, to next to other restaurants,” [co-owner Chris] Reynolds said. “We looked all over the city, we’ve been thinking about it for a good couple of years now. But the waterfront made a lot of sense to us, because it’s where a lot of people spend a lot of their time outside.”

Waterfront Development agreed to a space at the foot of Salter Street, near the Waterfront Warehouse. The Stillwell owners also put a lot of thought and work into creating a bar out of a shipping container:

The container was designed by Eric Stotts of Skin + Bones Building Design Workshop Inc. — Stotts is an uncle of Reynolds and MacDonald, who are siblings — and built in Burnside by CTS Container & Trailer Services Ltd. The tent-like structure that sits on top of the container was manufactured by Able Canvas near Moncton.

Reynolds said after nearly two years of work, from conception to construction, the structure looks like it belongs in the space.

This was a risky and dare I say bold initiative. Would Halifax’s iffy weather cooperate? Would Stillwell get caught up in Halifax’s love/hate relationship with alcohol?

But the beer garden was a tremendous success. I went there a lot after work last summer, as did thousands of other downtown office workers, the hipster crowd, tourists, and passersby. A nice little community formed on the steps and picnic tables, in the shade of the trees, overlooking the harbour. Besides old friends I’d meet up with at the garden, I probably met a dozen people I’d never known before. It was everything a beer garden should be.

But the Restaurant Association of Nova Scotia filed a complaint. It wasn’t fair, said RANS, that other restaurant owners didn’t have the opportunity to come up with an original idea, work on it for two years, and pitch an entirely new concept to Waterfront Development.

I guess that’s how capitalism works nowadays: creativity is an unfair market advantage.

And so Waterfront Development was forced to put the beer garden spot out to tender, and Joseph McGuinnes, who owns the wannabe gastro bar Stubborn Goat and fake Irish bar Durty Nelly’s (any bar that calls itself an Irish bar is annoyingly pathetic) low-balled the bid and won the contract for the beer garden spot. The garden now will be branded with the Stubborn Goat logo.

Me, I’ll go up the hill and drink with the unfair creative people.

3. The burning weed with its roots in hell

YouTube video

“From a psychiatric perspective, regular use of cannabis in adolescence is associated with the development of psychotic disorders, depression, anxiety disorders and an increased risk of suicidal thoughts [in teenagers],” Dr. Selene Etches tells the CBC.

See also: teenagers who don’t smoke pot.

4. Wild Kingdom

This Cuvier's beaked whale was found at New Harbour. Photo: E. Zwamborn/ Marine Animal Response Centre
This Cuvier’s beaked whale was found at New Harbour. Photo: E. Zwamborn/ Marine Animal Response Centre

“A rare whale found on a beach in Nova Scotia will eventually be on public display in the New Brunswick Museum,” reports the CBC. “The Cuvier’s beaked whale was found alive, stranded on a beach in New Harbour, N.S., on Feb. 7. It is likely the first recorded discovery of such a whale in the Atlantic region.”


1. Cranky letter of the day

To the Inverness Oran:

I would like to apologize to Inverness County Council as it seems that I have insulted you and that my efforts to analyse and critique the airport proposal seems to have offended you. I assume this from the fact that council has not responded to any of my inquiries for additional information, nor have they refuted any claims that I made in my four articles earlier this year about the proposal.

The purpose of my submissions was that after doing a fairly thorough review of the proposal, I had very significant concerns with the proposal and the motivation for the proposal. I am sorry that Warden MacAulay and CAO O’Connor felt so threatened by this analysis that they asked to meet with me at Engage Inverness County in 2015, without asking me prior to the event, behind closed doors instead of publically. At this meeting, the only outcome was that Warden MacAulay felt that I had a lot of energy and that he asked that I direct that energy for the positive of the county. 

Well, I am also sorry that Warden MacAulay does not seem to think an analysis of a $9 million proposal by our council by a Chartered Professional Accountant with 22 years of experience in reading and preparing proposals, financial statements and projections and advising not-for-profits, individuals and businesses as a positive thing for our county. 

I had attended the Cheticamp public consultation on the proposal and had planned on reading my analysis at this meeting but I would have used up the 20-minute question and answer period, which I thought unfair to the other attendees. This 20-minute limit was a joke perhaps meant to limit the public consultation in my opinion. The presentation was skimmed over by council. 

I am also sorry that I corrected the warden as to whether the proposal would cost any more than the three million dollars to the rate payers. You see, he indicated that the airport was projected on a break-even basis. However, the proposal indicates about $120,000 being contributed by the county to making the airport, so call, break-even which I had to point out to the warden and the public at large. Unfortunately, there is much more cost than I had previously determined as I perused the proposal further. 

I have been slow at getting back to the people of the county on this since I have been in a battle with the county to access information that the public should have access to. My access to information request I sent October 19th, 2015 was not responded to within 30 days required and I had to file a complaint with the Provincial Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Nova Scotia who finally forced the Municipality to comply with Nova Scotia Law. 

In the coming weeks I will point out another $114,000 in costs in the first year of operation of the airport not accounted for. This cost is estimated to total between $600,000 and $1,140,000 over 10 years. I will break down the true value of the jobs that council hopes will repopulate the county, highlight the annual shortfalls that the county has incurred in operations (losses) and highlight that based on current trends, residents of the county that do not get county water will be subsidizing the areas that do have county water. All this and more. 

In the mean time, I ask area residents that are not happy with the county to make your voice known because this is all happening while our CAO, Mr. O’Connor got a 4.8 per cent pay raise in 2014 and another 5.3 per cent pay raise in 2015 and is now making almost $123,000 per year based on the audited financial statements. 

As a final note, as I look today at the county website, the airport proposal seems to have been removed. Anyone wanting a copy of the proposal and my previous submissions may e-mail me at and I will send you a PDF copy of these.

Daniel Paturel, Margaree



Halifax & West Community Council (6pm, City Hall) — Samir Metlej wants to build another crappy seven-storey apartment building in the Isleville/Almon area.


Public Accounts (9am, Province House) — Janet Knox, prez of the Nova Scotia Health Authority, and Peter Vaughan, deputy minister of the  Department of Health and Wellness, will be questioned about Mental Health Services, Programs and Strategy.

On Campus


YouTube video

Out of the Past (8pm, Dalhousie Art Gallery) — a screening of the 1947 film directed by Jacques Tourneur.

In the harbour

Screen Shot 2016-02-17 at 8.52.01 AM

OOCL Italy, container ship, Cagliari, Italy to Fairview Cove, then sails to sea


I’ll be on The Sheldon MacLeod Show, News 95.7, at 4pm.

Tim Bousquet is the editor and publisher of the Halifax Examiner. Twitter @Tim_Bousquet Mastodon

Join the Conversation


Only subscribers to the Halifax Examiner may comment on articles. We moderate all comments. Be respectful; whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims. Please read our Commenting Policy.
  1. Does it actually take 3 hours of Regional Council’s time do do what the Mayor should have been able to do in about 2 minutes? And if a good Samaritan effort does not deserve a warning ticket, I do not know what does. Enough said… the whole thing was overblown in their own way by ALL parties concerned.

  2. What is unfair about the Stillwell thing is as obvious to me as everyone else. But I’ve also been wondering another thought about this today, and it may well be a terrifically ignorant thought, given that I have never operated a business. What I’ve been wondering is whether the Stubborn Goat’s move, complaining to RANS or plying whatever network they have, is something that the Stillwell folks would never do in their own interest. Or to put it another way, I see what happened is “unfair” in general, but am not sure if in business there is a different sensibility about the concept of fairness. Sometimes I get the feeling that eating the other guy’s lunch is actually written right into the 101 textbook. But again, I am musing from zero first hand knowledge.

  3. Oh yeah the Stillwell thing is absolutely outrageous.

    It’s apparent now what creativity and innovation gets you.

    Ridiculous (and I don’t even drink)!

  4. Lord knows I have no love for self important police dicks and private citizens have every right to express whatever they want on social media.

    I’m sure Matt Whitman has a private life but it seems his well crafted persona (dare I say BRAND) is so intertwined with his identity as a councillor that what he says as a councillor and private citizen are intertwined.

    Hence his opinions are a reflection on council. Our learned (and I used that term loosely), democratically elected representatives have decided the same.

    I tend to agree with them though given the things I see Tuesday nights it’s hard to believe their regular meetings shouldn’t begin with an apology.

    “Citizens of H/\LIF/\X.

    We apologize in advance for our undermining and general besmirchment of democracy this evening…..”

  5. Dunno, do you think possibly that maybe the guy with the ATV got ticketed for several reasons besides putting snow back in the street? Diana in Kingswood goes nowhere, normally you only see a cop at an intersection or heading to a call. I live in the neighbourhood and ATVs unlicensed, on trails not cleared for motorized vehicles etc are a fairly common incident. Plow services routinely push snow from driveways onto the side of the road after city plows have cleared and get away with it because it’s in the middle of nowhere. Likely a local was bent over what was going on and called in the horsemen. The councillor was over the top with his social media criticism, if he ad not informed the whole world of his displeasure and gone to the RCMP direct he wouldn’t be on his “apology tour”. I’m a bit surprised it wasn’t the RCMP supervisor who would make a complaint in support of their member. As to council’s response to the hurt feelings and Whitman…imagine a crab in a bucket full of crabs trying to climb out and leave the others behind. One, some, or all the crabs will latch on to the escapee and pull it back or try to climb over it.

  6. I was uncomfortable with Whitman’s tweet, not because police should be above criticism nor because I thought the ticket was justified, but because as an elected municipal official, it’s inappropriate for Whitman to use Twitter as a venue to complain about public servants.

    This isn’t the first time Whitman has taken to Twitter to criticize city staff. I can specifically recall complaints about plow operators and planning and operational staff, and I know I’ve seen others over the past three years.

    Twitter is an excellent venue for Joe Public to signal-boost legitimate grievances and oversights, and for people to rally others to their cause. #assholewithashovel is an excellent example of social media use. However, it’s decidedly not the place to discipline employees, especially without any sort of due process or recourse. Let’s not forget how receptive he is to criticism of any sort when it’s directed towards him. Better than most, Whitman should be aware of the recourses available to citizens who are dissatisfied with how public servants perform their duties.

    Once Matt Whitman reverts to private citizen status, he’s welcome to tweet whatever asinine and knee-jerk comments he likes. Hashtag to his heart’s content, even. But while he holds a position of municipal oversight, he’s responsible to maintain at least an appearance of being fair and thoughtful. For that reason, I’m glad council deliberated over the complaint and that Matt was directed to apologize and exercise better restraint in the future.

    1. Whitman’s comment in the Metro News :”Code of conduct is something we could look at more often,” Whitman said, adding that he thinks a social media policy should “grow out of that.”

      I realize that there is a disconnect between Halifax (Political) and the City of Halifax (Corporation), but there is already an established social media policy which states that an employee of the city cannot criticize the city openly.

      Perhaps a Councillor isn’t technically an employee of the city, but they should still be bound by the same policies that any employee is, myself included. When I started openly tweeting about transit and the ferries, my supervisor made sure that I had a copy of the social media policy so I could avoid getting into trouble. I figure that I’ve skirted the edge on more than a few occasions, but as long as I’m promoting the ferries I’m cool.

  7. My favourite part is Warnica’s gracious response to Whitman’s apology:

    “I’ll wait and review it tomorrow and see what kind of apology it is and we’ll go from there,” he said. “And if it’s a heartfelt apology, I guess I’ll accept that and we’ll look to work together in the future.”

    If Warnica’s in depth, day-long analysis of Whitman’s apology finds that it was in fact non-heartfelt, then Warnica will follow standard operating procedure and take take his toys home in a huff.

  8. The Stillwell beer garden debacle is just another example of everything that’s wrong with Halifax. The WDC should have manned up and told the RANS “Look, Stillwell did the legwork, they did the initial costs knowing that they could’ve lost their shirts, but it worked out for them. So they get to keep doing what they are doing. They had the idea, you didn’t. Tough shit.” Innovate (everyone drink!) is the big key/buzz word, but whenever anyone does, everyone else cries foul, cause they didn’t think of it first.

    1. I don’t think it has anything to do with “everything wrong with Halifax.” It has to do with the an entrenched and entitled industry association organizing to preserve a status quo they perceive as beneficial to their ranks. Trust me, the same thing happens all over, and food-industry organizations are notorious for it.

      Anyway, I definitely agree that the WDC screwed up. Either they should ave foreseen the trouble and been upfront with Stillwell about it, or told RANS to stuff it (if legally permissible; if not, they should simply have awarded the contract to Stillwell).

  9. It’s pretty disturbing that the culture of hurt fee-fees extends to police officers now. Maybe soon they’ll be authorized to use lethal force to protect their feels. I think there is something very disturbing about the western obsession with minimizing risk at all costs. It’s a good thing that people dying or getting injured on the job are no longer seen as a cost of doing business (which used to fall entirely on the worker) and that cannon fodder doesn’t exist in modern militaries, but as a culture we’re far too obsessed with safety. Maybe banning tag, fun jungle gyms, dangerous toys and of course, hurt feelings has unintended consequences when those children grow up into well, larger children and become police officers.

  10. First:
    Matt Whitman did a LOT to help me get an audience with the mayor and council last year with all the #assholewithashovel stuff. He’s a passionate guy and a person who wants to make Halifax a better place. He also does post a million Twitter kajiggers.

    Second: I like the police. I like the military. Nurses and firefighters I also have great affection for.

    That said: The whole Heroes thing has become a way to shut doen even legitimate criticism of the actions of these fine folks, and I intensely dislike it.
    Yes, they do heroic things.
    Since 9/11 the Cult of the Hero has been used to justify all kinds of shitty things on our behalf, like wars, wars in other places, bombing/drone striking people, and to shut us up about criticising the actions of the police.
    I understand how Matt’s “enthusiasm” could rub someone the wrong way, but every day someone on social media does the same and I choose to move on to something else. Maybe pics of GrumpyCat. Something less enragening.

    This thing with the Mountie felt like petty and vindictive prickery. The street is extremely difficult to plow so that everyone can get to work etc. The police should be more than ticket dispensaried and Yes/No Automatons. If they can figure out a way to plow the cul de sac in the future, that would be great. Until then a neighbour has stepped up to fix the problem.

    To make this all about me, I can absolutely understand why people would hate it every time I am in the media droning on, and me sitting streetside of a curbcuts, chipping ice or shovelling isn’t exactly legal. I could be ticketted. Instead I get the local cops saying good job or even grabbing my second shovel and pitching in.

    I’m with Matt. Sometimes you just have to do the thing because otherwise it isn’t getting done.

    Heroes and power tripping cops aside.