1. Stephen McNeil’s assault on democracy

Stephen McNeil. Photo: Halifax Examiner

Reports Jean Laroche for the CBC:

The committee at Nova Scotia’s Province House that’s been most effective at holding governments to account and squeezing information out of high-ranking officials will no longer be as freewheeling or topical as it has traditionally been.

The Liberal members on the powerful public accounts committee used their majority Wednesday to change the longstanding practice of allowing all three parties in the House to pick topics and decide who will be called before the committee.

From now on the committee will only deal with topics that stem directly from reports filed by Nova Scotia’s auditor general and only back as far as the report Auditor General Michael Pickup tabled on May 29.

This is outrageous.

Public Accounts is where opposition parties have been able to call government employees as witnesses and demand answers about issues the government would rather not see the light of day.

Public Accounts brings a degree of accountability that would not otherwise be possible, and it has been structured that way for as long as anyone can remember. Yesterday, former PC candidate Rob Batherson and I were discussing this, and we both agreed that all governments led by all three parties have followed the traditional format of Public Accounts since at least the Savage administration in the 1990s; it wouldn’t surprise me if the tradition started as long ago as Joe Howe’s administration.

Laroche reports that MLA Gordon Wilson is claiming responsibility for the change, but let’s not kid ourselves: such a monumental change to basic governance would not occur unless the premier agreed to it. Likely, it originated with Stephen McNeil.

Wilson and McNeil both used a bunch of mealy-mouthed and, frankly, insulting arguments to justify their power grab. Those arguments can be easily set aside.

Auditor General Michael Pickup does good work, but he has limited staff and resources, and his reports necessarily take time to produce. Public Accounts has allowed elected representatives to demand answers on breaking news stories and on issues Pickup may not have had the time or interest to investigate. Public Accounts has been more immediately responsive to citizen concerns.

There are any number of issues that demand immediate attention, and that may have not been covered to the depth necessary (or at all) by Pickup. Off the top of my head, I can think of the Yarmouth ferry, fracking, the offshore, the unified health board, the Halifax Convention Centre, the Donkin Mine, and the Sydney container pier. These are, necessarily, political issues. Opinions will differ, which is fine, but we cannot have informed public debate about them unless we have complete information, and that comes by placing government officials before the public and having them explain themselves. That’s been the role of Public Accounts.

But no longer. McNeil has now rigged the system such that opposition parties cannot independently call witnesses. McNeil may as well do away with Question Period.

Accountability? It’s to laugh for.

As Stephen McNeil sees it, his Liberal Party won an election and so it is therefore beyond question. Let’s review how McNeil and his government have cast disdain on accountability (this is a working list, and by no means exhaustive):

Working around public information laws. McNeil admitted he uses the telephone to conduct public business precisely to avoid leaving a paper trail that would allow the public to know what he is up to and how his government operates.

Lied about the security failure of the FOIPOP website, and unjustly accused a teenager of being a criminal. As I reported, government employees lied first to the Halifax Police about the security failure of the FOIPOP website, and then Internal Services Minister Patricia Arab misled the public about the failure. Worse still, McNeil blamed the whole fiasco on a hapless teenager, essentially convicting the teenager without trial, in order to blunt criticism of his government.

Downplayed the use of private email accounts to conduct government business and stymied investigation into the practice. As Stephen Kimber notes, as a candidate, McNeil promised that his government would give greater powers to the Information and Privacy Officer, but then when in office refused to allow the Information and Privacy Officer Catherine Tully to interview former Health Minister Leo Glavine about his use of a private email account to conduct government business.

Refuses to release a report into the death of inmate Clayton Cromwell. Cromwell died of a methadone overdose at the Burnside jail in April 2014, but McNeil’s government refuses to give a report on the death to the Canadian Press.

Withholding details about bedsores in nursing homes. Jennifer Henderson reports this morning that “efforts to obtain more recent information about the number of bedsores or the scope of the problem in Nova Scotia have been hampered by secrecy.”

And now, eviscerating Public Accounts. 

These actions go beyond party politics, and have nothing to do with traditional Liberal Party ideals, whatever you may think of them — as noted, past Liberal governments (and NDP and PC governments) did not conduct a wholesale attack on the notion of public accountability to the degree that McNeil has. This is not a political debate over policies and budgets and legislation, of which reasonable people can disagree; rather, this is assault on our democratic principles and processes.

Liberals should be outraged. Conservatives and New Democrats should be outraged as well. Everyone should be outraged.

Democracy is about much more than elections. It’s about public participation, which can only occur with an informed citizenry with the necessary access to information about how its government operates. But McNeil is ruling as an autocrat, answerable to no one, and beyond question.

His actions are part of a broader trend in government. McNeil’s Conservative counterpart in Ontario, Doug Ford, argues that even the courts have no jurisdiction over him because he was elected and judges were appointed — a fundamental misunderstanding of our democratic processes.

Here in Nova Scotia, McNeil’s actions will have a profound effect on how the province is governed into the future, but the most immediate effect will probably be at the municipal level.

Halifax councillor David Hendsbee recently argued that the city’s freedom of information budget be cut; he apparently believes providing legally mandated information to citizens is too costly.

And earlier this week, Tully issued a report on the failure of the King’s County officials to comply with freedom of information laws, and demanded that county officials comply within 10 days. But why should they? If the premier doesn’t have to comply with the laws, why should they?

Stephen McNeil has set the tone for a fundamentally undemocratic form of governance.

Democracy itself is at stake.

2. Torstar starts paid subscriptions

This morning, Torstar announced it is beginning its paid subscription model, which will be applied to all its publications, including StarMetro Halifax.

Readers will be allowed up to five free articles per month. After that, subscriptions start at $14.99/month for a one-year commitment or $19.95/monthly without the annual commitment. Either way, the introductory month is 99 cents.

I endorse the move to paid subscriptions. I have already subscribed, and I encourage readers to do the same (after, of course, subscribing first to the Halifax Examiner).

StarMetro Halifax has a tiny newsroom that punches way above its weight, and especially so in covering the day-to-day news. It has become an essential part of the Halifax news scene.

“Like all news outlets in recent years,” writes Torstar CEO John Boynton, “the Toronto Star has been forced to deal with the economic challenges brought on by declining print advertising revenue and a continuing shift in our reader habits from the printed newspaper to digital and mobile devices, including smartphones, computers and tablets.”

That’s exactly right: the advertising-supported business model is dead, and continuing to rely on the dead tree newspaper is foolhardy. As I understand it, Torstar will likely abandon its dead tree newspapers in coming years and the publications will, like the Halifax Examiner, become solely internet-based.

Mourn the dead tree newspaper all you want — I understand its appeal — but don’t insist on it until you can tell me how it can survive financially. The simple fact is it doesn’t work any longer.

Some publications, like the Chronicle Herald, are doubling down with advertising on the dead tree, and the papers are morphing into advertising circulars stuffed with advertorials that insult the intelligence of readers. I feared that the former Metro was taking the same path, and that its annoying front page wraparound ads would infect the entire ethos of the publication; but thankfully, under Torstar, the rebranded StarMetro Halifax is taking the opposite route and betting that it can survive by maintaining standards and concentrating on reporting.

Best of luck to them.




Port Wallace PPC Meeting (Thursday, 6:30pm, HEMDCC Large Meeting Room 1, Alderney Gate) — no agenda posted.

Public Information Meeting – Case 21927 (Thursday, 7pm, Gym, Ocean View Elementary School, Eastern Passage) — application by Gary Edwards, who wants to build some commercial buildings behind the two apartment buildings that have already been approved at 1490 Main Road in Eastern Passage. This is to the left as you’re driving into Eastern Passage, just before the fork in the road.


Sewage Plant Estates Expo (Friday, 12pm, Centre Court, Scotia Square) — see what was produced by the “charrette” all week, and then tell them to blow up the casino and the parking garages.



Legislature sits (1pm-6pm, Province House)


Legislature sits (Friday, 9am-1pm, Province House)

On campus



Getting to the Heart of the Matter: Having Non-defensive Conversations (Thursday, 9am, Room 224, Student Union Building) — “one full-day foundations session and eight weekly half-days of practical applications.” Register here.

Examining the Relationship Between Structural Pathology and Clinical Pathology: Envisioning a Communitybased Health Research Mandate for Diverse Black Canadian Communities (Thursday, 11am, Room 2L7, Tupper Link) — Ingrid Waldron will speak. Info here.

Reflections Of An International Alum: Voyages In Maritime Affair (Thursday, 3pm, Room 204, Weldon Law Building) — Jay L. Batongbacal will speak.

Complex Event Recognition for Maritime Monitoring (Thursday, 4pm, Room 430, Goldberg Computer Science Building) — George Paliouras from the National Centre of Scientific Research “Demokritos” in Greece will speak.

Temple Grandin (Thursday, 4pm, Alumni Theatre, Cumming Hall, Agricultural Campus, Truro) — the talk is sold out, but it’s being livestreamed here.

Company Law and the Promotion of Social Policies (Thursday, 4:30pm, Room 104, Weldon Law Building) — Paul L. Davies from Harris Manchester College, Oxford, will speak. (Registration was required by September 7.)

White Coat Ceremony and Honorary Degree Conferral (Thursday, 5pm, Rebbecca Cohn Auditorium, Dalhousie Arts Centre) — the Faculty of Dentistry is giving Peter Cooney, the Chief Dental Officer of Canada, an honorary degree.

Our Energy Future: Lithium-ion Batteries and Electrochemical Energy Storage (Thursday, 7pm, Ondaatje Hall, Marion McCain Building) — Jeff Dahn will speak. Register here.


Madeleine Redfern

Madeleine Redfern (Friday, 11:30am, Room 127, Goldberg Computer Science Building) — Iqaluit Mayor Madeleine Redfern will talk about the Qikiatani Truth Commission.

Faculty of Dentistry Clinic Grand Opening and Renaming (Friday, 1pm, Level 2 Waiting Area, Dentistry Building)

Thesis Defence, Chemistry (Friday, 1:30pm, Room 3107, Mona Campbell Building) — PhD candidate Lin Ma will defend his ​​thesis, “Development of Novel Electrode/Electrolyte Systems for a Li-ion Cell with Higher Energy Density and Longer Lifetime.”

YouTube video

Dentist! (Friday, 3pm, Ondaatje Hall, Marion McCain Building) — Bill MacInnis will  get a Distinguished Services Award and then explain how to get paid to be inhumane.

Gauss Factorials, Jacobi Primes, and Generalized Fermat Numbers (Friday, 3pm, Room 227, Chase Building) — Karl Dilcher will present his joint work with John B. Cosgrave. Their abstract:

This talk is about various aspects of the Gauss factorial $N_n!$ which is defined as the product of all positive integers up to $N$ that are relatively prime to $n$. After a brief general discussion, I will present a variety of results which can be seen, roughly speaking, as extensions of Wilson’s theorem.

Of special interest will be the multiplicative order (and specifically order 1) of particular Gauss factorials modulo certain composites. The relevant results involve generalized Fermat numbers and a special and rare type of primes which we call Jacobi primes. Another class of results concerns the relationship between multiplicative orders modulo successive prime powers. These results are based on generalizations of binomial coefficient congruences of Gauss, Jacobi, and of Hudson and Williams.

Terry Anders Memorial Lecture (Friday, 3:30pm, Room P5260, Life Sciences Centre) — Richard Brown will talk about “What have I done in the last 48 years? How coming to Dalhousie as a graduate student shaped my life.”

Circled in with Enemies’ Countries: Privateers and Local Politics in Restoration Jamaica (Friday, 3:30pm, Room 1170, Marion McCain Building) — John Coakley from Merrimack College will speak.

Ignite: Dal’s Third Century (Friday, 6pm, Halifax Convention Centre) — reception and dinner. For just $149.50 (solo) or $1,495 (for a table of 10; this isn’t Costco, you don’t get a bulk purchase discount), you can listen to a bunch of people prattle on during “an evening of inspiration and discovery”:

Through immersive storytelling with three of our leading researchers, we’ll explore extraordinary perspectives on some of the greatest challenges facing humanity — food security, debilitating diseases and sustainable energy.

Weirdly, none of the event descriptions I have found say who the three speakers are. Maybe it’s the hockey coach, the groundskeeper, and the sadistic dentist above. No offence to the speakers, whoever they are, but the people who would pony up $149 for such an event are exactly the barrier to solving the greatest challenges facing humanity.

But if you want to pay $149.50 for a single ticket or $1,495 for a table of 10, no bulk purchase discount, you can do so here.

Oh, the dress code is business/cocktail with black and gold encouraged.

Saint Mary’s


The Routledge Handbook of the Politics of Migration in Europe (Thursday, 1pm, Room LI135, Patrick Power Library) — co-editor Lyubov Zhyznomirska will speak.

Doing the Right Thing at Home and Abroad: Why Values Matter (Thursday, 7pm, in the theatre named after a bank in the building named after a grocery store) — Bob Rae, who in addition to being, well, Bob Rae, is also Canada’s Special Envoy to Myanmar, will speak. Info here.


Natalie Slawinski

Inviting Engagement with Paradox: How Leaders of Social Enterprises Communicate Complexity (Friday, 11am, Sobey 260) — Natalie Slawinski from Memorial University will talk about the Shorefast Foundation, which is that Fogo Island thing started by Zita Cobb, the gazillionaire who is bringing prosperity forever, amen to the island by teaching formerly poor people how to service the obscenely wealthy.

This is the perfect encapsulation of our age: only obscenely wealthy people can save us.

(Send hate mail to… you know where.)

Kathleen Winter. Photo: Roger Lemoyne

Annabel (Friday, 12pm, Room LI135, Patrick Power Library) — Kathleen Winter will read from her book.

Mount Saint Vincent


Technologies of Unease (Friday, 2pm, Keshen Goodman Library) — Karen MacFarlane will speak.

In the harbour

5:30am: Atlantic Star, container ship, arrives at Fairview Cove from New York
6am: Radcliffe R. Latimer, bulker, sails from National Gypsum for sea
6:45am: Regal Princess, cruise ship with up to 4,271 passengers, arrives at Pier 22 from Saint John. The Regal Princess is on a seven-day cruise in and out of New York.
7:15am: Skogafoss, container ship, arrives at Pier 42 from Argentia, Newfoundland

Veendam. Photo: Halifax Examiner

7:15am: Veendam, cruise ship with up to 1,350 passengers, arrives at Pier 20 from Sydney. The Veendam is on a seven-day cruise from Montreal to Boston, arriving in Boston Saturday, then reversing course and heading back to Montreal; the Vendam is the workhorse of cruise ships in Atlantic Canada, and has been making this Montreal-Boston-and-back circuit all summer, but in October it moves down to the Caribbean, where it will run a Fort Lauderdale-Cuba circuit all winter. See the sordid history of the ship here.
8am: Dependable, cable layer, sails from Pier 9 for sea
10:45am: Victory II, cruise ship, sails from Pier 24 for sea
11am: Rt Hon Paul E Martin, bulker, arrives at National Gypsum from Norfolk
11am: Skogafoss, container ship, sails from Pier 42 for sea
Noon: Oceanex Sanderling, ro-ro container, moves from Pier 41 to Autoport
3:30pm: Veendam, cruise ship, sails from Pier 20 for Boston
4:30pm: Atlantic Star, container ship, sails from Fairview Cove for Liverpool, England
4:30pm: Oceanex Sanderling, ro-ro container, moves from Autoport back to Pier 41
5:45pm: Regal Princess, cruise ship, sails from Pier 22 for Boston
9pm: Star N, oil tanker, sail from Imperial Oil for sea
11pm: YM Movement, container ship, arrives at Fairview Cove from Norfolk


I had other stuff I wanted to write about today, but I took more time with the McNeil piece.

Tim Bousquet is the editor and publisher of the Halifax Examiner. Twitter @Tim_Bousquet Mastodon

Join the Conversation


Only subscribers to the Halifax Examiner may comment on articles. We moderate all comments. Be respectful; whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims. Please read our Commenting Policy.
  1. With a castrated foipop system and with a neutered public accounts procedure, why even bother submitting a foipop request or why bother having an opposition member chair the public accounts committee? It’s now all a waste of time!
    Auditor General Michael Pickup in an earlier report commented upon the need for the government to be accountable to the public. This Liberal government has ignored what was really a warning from the auditor general.
    There’s only one way to fix that, and it is at the ballot box.

  2. Saintly Progressive Canada is slowly turning into an ugly, ugly place. MacNeil is another manifestation of it. There’s a reason he and Doug Ford are good buds.

    Wake up Canada!! Wake up Nova Scotia!!!!!!!

    1. Wake up, indeed! I am disturbed by the dearth of reader feedback on this important story. For goodness sake, folks, if you’re outraged (and you should be!), say so! Exercise some goddamned agency and speak up in favour of fairness, decency and democracy! This province is in deeper shit than most people seem willing to admit.

  3. I don’t know where the error originated but, Madeleine Redfern is currently the Mayor of Iqaluit. She is also a former Mayor in that, after winning a by-election in 2010, she chose not to run in 2012. In 2015, she ran and won.

    1. Thanks for that correction. In searching for a photo I went to the site, where she’s described as the former mayor, and her recent re-election isn’t mentioned.