“To the premier of Nova Scotia, I dare you to take a meeting with me, and explain to me, and look into my eyes, and tell me that there is no health-care crisis in my province of Nova Scotia.” 

Inez Rudderham

It was probably too much to expect Premier Stephen McNeil to respond in any way other than with his usual bland, butt-covering bromides to Inez Rudderham’s heart-wrenching cri de coeur video about her own personal health care crisis:

  • about the fact Rudderham’s family doctor had left, making her just one more among the more than 50,000 Nova Scotians without a family physician;
  • about the fact she was turned away from under-staffed, over-worked emergency rooms three times over two years before someone finally ordered the exam that told her, in June 2018, she had stage three anal cancer;
  • about the fact that two rounds of chemotherapy and 30 rounds of radiation on her pelvis later, she is “barren and infertile;”
  • about the fact she is still only 33 and in menopause;
  • about the fact she hasn’t been able to work during her treatments and now has had to sell her family home to make ends meet and support her four-year-old daughter;
  • about the fact she asked, back in January, for mental health services to help her cope with all of this awfulness and just learned last week she finally has an appointment — for mid-July.
A photo of Stephen McNeil
Premier Stephen McNeil. Photo: Jennifer Henderson

Premier Stephen McNeil did not commit to meeting with Rudderham as she had dared him to do in that viral Facebook video now viewed more than 2.5 million times in less than a week. He didn’t agree to look her in the eyes and tell her there is no health care crisis in Nova Scotia. He didn’t even bother to call her.

“I obviously feel for this person,’” he allowed to reporters. “I did see part of the video.” But instead of talking to her directly, facing the “face of the health care crisis” in Nova Scotia, McNeil hid behind the usual bureaucratic bafflegab.

“I’ve asked the department to reach out, to be in contact with her to find out the issues that she has and how we can best ensure that she gets the appropriate treatment but also the appropriate supports.”

Health Minister Randy Delorey sang from the same sorry hymnal: “I think, again, there’s some very specific concerns that were being raised about an individual’s personal experiences within the health-care system… I think the health authority’s taking the right approach to reach out, to connect … with the individual as they do and provide opportunities.”

All of which seemed to suggest Rudderham’s problems are specific and anomalous. Fix them and we fix the problem. Health care crisis? What health care crisis?

“There are challenges in the health care system in… access to primary care,” McNeil explained, sticking to his stale, a-challenge-is-not-a-crisis mantra. “We’ve always acknowledged that. But we’ve continued to make adjustments.”

Challenges, adjustments, no crisis, nothing to see here, folks…

Those who work inside the system, of course, know better.

So do those — like Inez Rudderham — who are failed by the health care system.

“Health care in Nova Scotia is in crisis,” correctly sums up Jason McLean, president of the Nova Scotia Government and General Employees Union, which represents the majority of health care workers in the province. “Everyone who works in health care knows it. Every person who tries to get health care knows it. Only the McNeil Liberals refuse to acknowledge it.”

Simply acknowledging the crisis won’t solve it, of course. The health care crisis in this province is complex and longstanding, and so multi-faceted it is hard to even wrap your head around.

But pretending there isn’t one makes it impossible to even begin the real work of addressing it.

Stephen Kimber is an award-winning writer, editor, broadcaster, and educator. A journalist for more than 50 years whose work has appeared in most Canadian newspapers and magazines, he is the author of...

Join the Conversation


Only subscribers to the Halifax Examiner may comment on articles. We moderate all comments. Be respectful; whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims. Please read our Commenting Policy.
  1. The health authority merger has been a fiasco – gajillions of dollars spent trying to make this plan work. Shared Services is another fiasco – millions of dollars burned away trying to fit a square peg into a round hole, particularly when you look at the IT component of Shared Services: 7 million dollars spent on a horrible software product (Axios Assyst) for the Shared Services help desk. Money has been tossed about and wasted on these grandiose plans and the result has been nothing but poor service. Nova Scotia under McNeil’s watch has been a proper shit-show.

  2. There’s definitely a crisis but then there are the puzzling statistics. There are more physicians per capita in NS than any other province yet they’re the lowest paid and most highly taxed. I’m not sure why the government can continue to collect tax from people for whom they can’t provide basic services.

  3. As long as Premier McNeil sees running a surplus as the prime objective of Liberal government, the deep deficits in health care, education and social services will continue unattended.

  4. This is the perfect example of the personal becoming the universal.

    Who in their right mind cannot see themselves in Inez? Why our premier of course!

  5. McNeil still refuses to take ownership of his actions in wrecking a prosperous NS film and TV industry that was bringing outside money here and is not a shadow of its former self. Don’t expect him to man up and accept this province is suffering a health care crisis under his watch. The government is replacing the Centennial Building. What more do you want?

    Until the NS Auditor General is given free reign to examine the financial and management practices of the NSHA, health horror stories like this will continue, until one day someone takes the government to court in our very own Chaouli case that could well open the door to for-profit-medicine because the wait times and the outcomes of NS public health care have been allowed to become unconscionable. Then we would all have the best health care our money could buy.

    Maybe that was where our free-enterprise minded premier was headed all along?