People in the mental health community who are close to family members of a 45-year-old man are speaking out after the man was admitted to hospital with gangrene in his stomach. The patient, who lives with schizophrenia, has been in and out of the East Coast Forensic Hospital for the past 20 years. Family members have requested that the man remain anonymous at present to preserve his dignity and humanity while he is being treated.
Sheila Hiles, the mother of Greg Hiles who died by suicide at the facility in August, told the Examiner in text messages that “it is nothing but horror stories” from patients in the institution. Sheila is outraged that the province refused to inquire into the death of her son. She says that her son’s case raised issues about the conditions in the facility, and this current case demonstrates the “neglect people like my son are living with every day.”
She has never been contacted by the facility since her son’s death, nor has she received any of her son’s personal effects. Sheila suffered a stroke following her son’s death, and struggles to speak. She cannot call the Hospital herself to communicate. She says the stress of her son’s death and the lack of answers led to her stroke.
According to members of the family of the man with gangrene, while he was a patient at the East Coast Forensic Hospital, the man underwent surgery for hernias. He was placed into a “quiet room” (the hospital’s term for segregation) and nobody checked on his incisions. Despite the man’s mental health history, no nurse was assigned to monitor his wounds. He was released from segregation two to three weeks ago and discharged into the community with no follow-up. The family say his condition upon release was “horrific”; even his toe nails had not been cut.
The surgical wounds were infected, and the man was rushed to hospital where he was admitted to the ICU. He has since undergone multiple surgeries. The infection had progressed to the point that gangrene developed in the wounds. When members of the family questioned how the facility could not have noticed such a severe infection — a condition that smells like rotting flesh — they allege that they were told that people with schizophrenia do not clean themselves well, and so staff could not tell there was a problem.
Sheila Hiles says that this level of medical negligence shows that issues in the hospital are systemic, and that there is an urgent need for the province to review the medical care and conditions in the facility. Hiles messaged the Examiner:
I don’t know how they are so oblivious to the problems with the whole system over there. All the money they get to care for patients, and what happens to them? The dehumanizing way staff in that facility speak about and treat people who are supposed to be under their care is disgusting.
My son should still be alive. He would have been 40 next week, a milestone in a person’s life. And now another family has a son in critical condition. The stories about abuse at that place need to get out there and be heard.
Martha Paynter, a PhD candidate and nurse who is the founder of Women’s Wellness Within, says that unfortunately these kinds of medical conditions are common in correctional settings. She says cases like an infection escalating to gangrene are caused by systemic issues:
There is not enough attention to physical well-being and carceral facilities are known to have poor hygienic conditions. This results in circumstances that allow an escalation of harm.
What cases like this show is that it is a persistent myth that carceral facilities are an adequate health care resource for people experiencing social marginalization. When we combine the goals of treatment with punishment we will inevitably fail.
The East Coast Forensic Hospital shares a site with the Central Nova Scotia Correctional Facility (the Burnside jail). Prisoners in Burnside are reporting that a fungal skin infection is spreading through the facility. They allege that despite nurses ordering that those affected must be able to shower, prisoners who have been locked down and are in segregation have been denied showers for days. One prisoner who spoke to me this weekend from segregation said the conditions in the facility are so bad he has thought about killing himself.
Gangrene and fungal infections are preventable with adequate hygiene. That serious infections are contracted and spread in these facilities should be alarming, and has health consequences not only for prisoners, but for members of the community. Prisoners serving weekends or short term sentences in the jail, for example, can easily spread the infection to family members. Staff are also placed at risk from the unhygienic environment. Lack of access to showers or basic post-surgical care creates conditions that are easily avoidable in 21st Century Canada.
The refusal of the province to investigate these facilities even when deaths occur indicates that the neglect is not just limited to staff in the facilities, but goes to the highest levels in this province. If deaths are not enough, and patients ending up in critical care is not enough, what level of suffering should we expect and tolerate before somebody looks into the conditions in these institutions?
Advocates for the East Coast Prison Justice Society have called upon the province to review deaths in custody. Medical care and the physical conditions of the province’s jails and mental health facilities are also in urgent need of investigation. What takes place in these facilities is hidden. It is past time to listen to mothers like Sheila Hiles and shine a light.
The Halifax Examiner is an advertising-free, subscriber-supported news site. Your subscription makes this work possible; please subscribe.
As Dostoyevski said, “The degree of civilization in a society can be judged by entering its prisons.”
We do not live in a civilized society. Neoliberal austerity is a reversion to medieval barbarism, except today’s feudal lords and their government vassals like Stephen McNeil pretend to be acting on behalf of the peasants.
Thanks to the Examiner and El Jones for keeping us informed about these horrific human rights abuses happening right under our noses.
A report should be filed with the College of Nurses of Nova Scotia. I sincerely hope that the ICU to which the patient was admitted did file a complaint. The family may also file a negligence suit with personal injury lawyers. That would drag ECFH in to the public eye.
Is the way inmates are treated at these Burnside facilities comparable to the same in other provincial and federal facilities?
I keep hearing horror stories from these places.
I keep hearing about inmates being poked in “administrative segregation” for long periods despite having commited no infractions to justify that (considered a form of torture by the UN).
Of people having necessary medications denied – or at least seriously delayed, to the detriment of their health.
Of people suffering mental issues being put with the general prison population and punished for behavioural issues ultimately related to their mental health state with doses of solitary.
Of people being beaten up and sexually assaulted there.
Of the proportion of Black and indigenous inmates being multiples of their proportion in the wider population. Why?
I hear a prisoner just maintaining phone contact with their family – with whom they hope to re-establish a better life after rehabilitation – is made so expensive that it’s impossible to stay in touch.
Some of these people are on remand – i.e. they’ve never been convicted of the crime for which they were charged. They may well be innocent but unable to post bail.
Evidently the Liberals are aware of all this and quite content to continue operating “corrections” like Soviet gulags: after all, there are few votes in running NS jails humanely, are there?
Judges sentencing the convicted are forced to use provincial jails like Burnside and are helpless to change the way they are run. There really are some nasty characters in our midst who deserve to be there. However the courts do not sentence these people to be abused or tortured. They put them there to deny them their freedom as punishment, to protect the public from them, to make an example of them to discourage others and (hopefully) to rehabilitate them. Other than that they should be treated in a civil, if firm, manner.
I guess we have to wait until something goes so horribly wrong at Burnside that the secrecy-obsessed McNeil government cannot smother it – something like a major prison riot perhaps – one that will attract an in depth enquiry they cannot control. Public property will have to be severely damaged and lives lost before this can be fixed – if it can at all.
I wonder how many NS voters would be happy to hear their government carries out systemic human rights abuses in their name?
They weren’t checking his wounds? That is outrageous. Does anyone know which “professional” body these people are responsible to?